Sixty-Two Before I Open My Eyes
My hand reaches the nightstand before I know I’m awake. Fingers feel along the wood in the dark, find the phone under the charging cable, flip it face up. The light hits eyes still glued shut and I squint the way you do at oncoming headlights on a country road. At the top, inside an orange ring, sits a number: sixty-two. Below it, in smaller type, two words. Poor sleep.
Only then do I feel tired.
The delay is tiny, half a second maybe, but I register it precisely. Before the orange ring there was a body stretched out in bed, legs heavy in a way that could have been fatigue or just the warmth of the sheets, mouth a little dry, a thought already drifting toward the ten o’clock meeting. A state with no name yet, waiting for someone to listen to it. After the ring, that state has a name and a verdict, and the rest of the morning lines up behind it. The stairs feel steeper. I make the coffee a double. At eleven, stuck on a long email I can’t seem to finish, I catch myself thinking: of course, on a sixty-two, what did I expect.
The score got there before the feeling, and I let it take the feeling’s place.
Nobody asked me to. All night the watch on my wrist logged the movements of my arm, my breathing and my heart; an algorithm turned that into an estimate, and the app packaged it as a score out of a hundred, complete with a color and an adjective. The last step, the one that mattered, I took myself, eyelids still puffy, feet not yet on the floor: I picked up that estimate and used it as a mirror. In it I saw the tired person that sixty-two described.
A Name for a New Anxiety
For a few months I thought this was my problem alone, a small neurosis of someone used to measuring everything. Then I found out it has a name, and that the name is nearly a decade old.
In February 2017, sleep psychologist Kelly Glazer Baron, then at Rush University Medical Center in Chicago, co-authored with colleagues from Northwestern University a paper in the Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine about three patients, three people who had turned up at a sleep clinic with a very close relationship to the charts on their devices. The authors called the condition orthosomnia, “ideal” sleep, building the word on the model of orthorexia, the obsessive preoccupation with eating healthily. A lot already lives inside that borrowing. The search for perfect sleep has the same shape as the search for the perfect plate, and the same risk of wearing away the pleasure it started from.
Read one after another, the three cases have the quality of a short story. There’s a thirty-nine-year-old man who gets the device as a gift from his partner, becomes convinced his tiredness only shows up after nights under eight hours, and sets himself a precise target: eight hours, every night. From then on he goes to bed with a test to pass. There’s a twenty-seven-year-old woman who wakes up unrefreshed after nights her device records as terrible. In the lab, polysomnography, the test that tracks the activity of the brain, the heart and other parameters during sleep, shows plenty of deep sleep instead. She keeps trusting her wrist. And there’s a sixty-nine-year-old man for whom the device was, at least in part, one of the nudges toward a correct diagnosis. All three had started spending more and more time in bed to push the count up, the opposite of what sleep therapists recommend.
The authors themselves noted that these devices can’t accurately tell sleep stages apart. In the university’s press release, Baron put it in even more domestic terms: the trackers struggle to separate light sleep from deep sleep, and they can count time spent reading in bed as sleep.
It’s worth keeping the boundaries tight. Three cases, described at one sleep clinic in the United States: nobody knows how many people go through something similar, the paper doesn’t try to estimate it, and it doesn’t claim that people who wear a sensor on their wrist sleep worse than those who don’t. The detail that stuck with me, even more than the stories, sits in a single line of the abstract. To the patients, the device data often seemed truer to their experience of sleep than validated tests did. The twenty-seven-year-old woman had a complete tracing of her sleeping brain in front of her and chose the screen on her wrist. That’s the new anxiety: the instrument’s account becomes more believable than the body’s, even when the body is being heard through electrodes.
From Effort to Rest, Measurement Moves Into the Bedroom
My first heart rate strap was a band of stiff plastic that in winter landed on my sternum like a blade of ice and by evening left a red line under my pecs. Then came the GPS watch that followed my miles by satellite, buzzing on my wrist at every completed lap. These were tools built for effort, for the speed of a lap and the heart climbing in the final interval. In that setting the number made clean sense. It left a trace of work that had actually happened and let you compare one Tuesday with the Tuesday a month before. On good days it confirmed what the legs already knew.
Then the watch stayed on my wrist at night too. I found myself sleeping in it without ever deciding to, because it was comfortable and the strap was already buckled. Along with the object, its grammar came into the bedroom. Score, goal, streak, personal best. Recovery, which in training plans had been the empty space between two sessions, the white of the page between one exercise and the next, became one more column to fill.
Rereading Baron’s cases, I recognize the move those patients made, stretching the night to push up the total. It’s the same thing I do on certain Sundays, when I tack on two and a half slow, pointless miles to close the week on a round number — junk miles, there for the spreadsheet more than for the legs. Lying in bed an extra hour with my eyes open so the sensor logs a few more minutes is the same move carried under the covers: volume for the sake of the count.
In effort, willpower works. Sleep only comes once you stop wanting it.
This is where the crossover gets strange. During a workout you can push and grit your teeth through the last mile, and often the body answers. Sleep behaves like a cat called by name too insistently: the harder you chase it, the farther it slips away. A logic designed to get more out of a working body, applied to a body that’s supposed to let go, risks producing the opposite of what you’re after. The sharpest image is still that thirty-nine-year-old man lying down in the dark with his eight-hour goal, like the night before an exam.
Permission to Feel Rested
Every morning, for months, I asked a sensor for permission to feel rested.
Put that way it sounds like an indictment of technology, yet the charge doesn’t hold up even inside the paper that gave the problem its name. One of the three patients had moved closer to a diagnosis partly thanks to that data. Baron herself acknowledged that tracking your sleep over time helps you form a rough idea of how much you’re getting. A trend across several weeks makes sense the way weekly mileage does for a runner, because it points in a direction. The trouble starts when that estimate becomes the first sentence of the day, spoken before the body has had a chance to say anything.
For a few weeks now I’ve reversed the order. The phone spends the night in the kitchen. When I wake up I lie still for a minute and take the inventory I used to take as a kid without knowing it: the weight of my legs under the blanket, whether my eyes open right away or ask for another moment, whether my jaw is clenched or loose, the first thought that arrives, whether it’s a worry or just the gray light on the curtain. Then the stairs and the moka pot. Only after that, if I feel like it, do I look at the ring.
Sometimes it matches. Sometimes it doesn’t, and that’s where things get interesting. There are mornings on a fifty-eight when I head out for a run and my legs turn over lightly from the first traffic light, and mornings on an eighty-five when my calves feel packed with wet sand. That gap between the estimate and the feeling, which I used to treat as my own error, I now think of as a space of competence. Anyone who has tried running without a watch knows the disorientation of those first miles with nothing to check on the wrist, and then the discovery that the breath already knew a pace. In the morning something similar happens, with less sweat.
Reclaiming the feel of waking up is a tiny gesture, almost ridiculous to describe. But there’s an act of trust inside it: granting your body the right to speak first, even when its voice is muddled, even when it gets things wrong, and putting the instrument back where it belongs, in the role of a second opinion.
This morning the ring read fifty-nine. I looked at it in the kitchen, mug in hand, after my legs on the stairs had already told me about a different night.